[DKP Survey] Jewelry VS 2NE1 ,who are the "Umbrella" Queens??

For today's DKP survey,we will make a comparison between 2NE1 and Jewelry!

I think many of you have seen 2NE1's LIVE performance of "Umbrella" at Music Bank before,right??

Jewelry also performed Rihanna's "Umbrella" on Kim Jung Eun's Chocolate aired yesterday.

There are videos of their performances for you to make comparison,you can also vote on the poll provided,so whose version do you like the most,Jewelry or 2NE1?

2NE1's version

Jewelry's version

38 Responses so far.

  1. apple from philippines says:

    2ne1 s the best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  2. Anonymous says:

    love 2ne1 better..

  3. I think 2ne1 is better than Jewelry
    I love 2ne1

  4. J says:

    2NE1 better.....

  5. Anonymous says:

    2NE1~ Fierce~

  6. Anonymous says:

    Poor Jewlery no one supports them XD. Fight I'm on your side!!!

  7. Anonymous says:


  8. Anonymous says:

    I don't think polls should include 2NE1 anymore...their fans think that they are just the best in everything...they don't care about the quality. As long as 2NE1 is included they'll think it's the best perf.

  9. Anonymous says:

    2ne1 is better...

  10. Anonymous says:

    I think Jewelry is better ( i'm not the fan of both girl bands)

  11. Anonymous says:

    emm plz watch the video and decide..after u watch,u know whose better..dont make stupid statement without watch it..jewelry so engrish and they sound weird singing english..2ne1 is not perfect too but atleast not engrish..so thats y...

  12. Anonymous says:


  13. Anonymous says:

    i like Jewelry's performance of Lady Marmalade but they didn't do very well on Umbrella. So I have to go with 2ne1.

  14. Anonymous says:

    first off, not a biased opinion: 2ne1 did better. but they both did well. just the first one had more energy. but Jewelry's marmalade was really good.

  15. Anonymous says:

    2NE1 was a little better at the english lol and it seemed like they had a little more energy in it..don't get me wrong I'm a fan of both the groups...Jewlery's Lady Marmalade was very good tho =D

  16. Anonymous says:

    I am a fan of neither group, but I do agree that 2NE1 did a better rendition of umbrella but that's b/c the song fits them more than Jewelry. I would have to see 2NE1 try songs that is out of their genre to see if they could pull it off. I also agree with one of the above comments that 2NE1 fans just don't give a fair critique to other girl groups whenever 2NE1 is involved. If that's the point then why even bother comparing anyone with 2NE1. Too biased.

  17. Anonymous says:

    I like Jewelry better

  18. Anonymous says:

    im not being biased but 2ne1 is better. they have better english and more energy...notice the fans' cheering, who got the crowd?

  19. Anonymous says:

    I like both Jewelry and 2NE1, but 2NE1 has better English and seems to have a stronger, clearer voice.

  20. Anonymous says:

    2NE1 is the best!! it's not biased just look the audience they fell dull...what a BORING!!! they like a puppet, we can't understand what they are singing..there English???? oh!!!Engrish...

  21. Anonymous says:

    in korea ppl say u r fluent in eng actually u r not??
    hyoyeon chinese is also not fluent wad an insult

  22. Anonymous says:

    i think jewelry might fit the image better of what rihanna was trying to portray, but 2ne1 sang it better

  23. Anonymous says:

    WTH are these comments? Eversince 2NE1 entered the KPOP scene, I've never seen so many rude fans! Saying you're not biased and yet you're saying that "2NE1 is the best" is so STUPID! You don't even know how to respect 2NE1's seniors!

    Koreans have accents and some stupid 2NE1 fans are dissing them? You're english are not even grammatically correct!

    This is the reason why I hate 2NE1!

    Maybe it's true, that ever since Dara entered KPOP she brought with her some rude and annoying fans! I hate you DARA! You talentless bitch! You whore! Go back to the Philippines! You belong there along with your rude and stupid fans! I hope antis will kill you! I'll be waiting!

  24. Anonymous says:

    2ne1 version of umbrella is more better compare to jewelry version because jewelry version of umbrella I can’t understand their English, their tongue is twisted I can’t even understand a word of what they are saying and jewelry pronunciation is very bad and they lack energy while performing and their voice here is weak compare to 2ne1 version very alive and loud and full of energy plus the choreography is great. The words are clear unlike to jewelry they look like they are eating the words of the song. Im not just saying this just because I love 2ne1 and I have nothing against jewelry its JUST IM STATING A FACT THAT 2NE1 version is more better.

  25. Anonymous says:

    ^YOUR ENGLISH SUCK! "more better?" LOL!

    And whatever you're saying is not "A FACT" it's an opinion, nothing more than that! All Koreans who didn't go overseas have difficulty in English!

  26. Anonymous says:

    I liked neither. 2NE1 sounded shaky (except for CL and minzy wasn't that bad either) and Jewelry was bland and boring. Especially didn't like the short-haired girl's vocals.

    I know I shouldn't criticise their english, but both groups pronunciation left something to be desired. It came off really awkward.

    P.s: if this comment seems familiar it's because I also posted it on youtube.

  27. Anonymous says:

    to stupid anonymous at 7:58
    hate the fans, not the idol...its being unfair for 2ne1 esp. to dara being hated bec. of their fans, did they done something wrong to you,huh?!
    and to other fans that keep on bashing other groups, you shut up and just support who you want,ok?!! bec. of you, your idol 2ne1 is being hated by others!! just think about it...

  28. Anonymous says:

    anonymous at 7:58,
    isnt u who being rude?
    i bet ur a fan of whoever but still, ur the one who bashed.
    its true that some are bias, so wats the deal about it? u can be biased too ^,- but never bash the group or the members of the group. (if u do, ul regret it)
    haha ul be killed in a heartbeat by this biased fans of 2ne1 u called.

  29. Anonymous says:

    2ne1 the BEST!!!
    2ne1 ah gogogo

  30. Anonymous says:

    Jewelry's singing is breathy. It must be because of the English syllabication. Their English is not good at all. Their singing is strained and their voices are not rounded, full and well-projected. Now, compare these points with 2NE1's performance and you'll see why 2NE1 comes out as the better performer of "Umbrella" between the two.

  31. Anonymous says:

    based on the videos that i saw its' soo clear that 2ne1 has the better perf. I'm not being biased here just telling the truth from what i've saw!!

  32. Anonymous says:

    yeah. 2ne1's version is better. sorry but it's the truth.

  33. Anonymous says:

    to people that are saying 2ne1 fans are making 2ne1 look bad bcuz we think they are good at everything, and that 2ne1 fans are not respecting 2ne1's sinors THATS just plain stupid if 2ne1 are better than their seniors at something like here at umbrella per. then we have the right to prise our girls and not take anything away from them



  34. Anonymous says:

    First of all, im just stating my OWN opinion here! okey?

    I chose 2ne1 over Jewelry. Why? Because perf wise they're more energetic than Jewelry. PERIOD.

    HOPE you will stop bashing about the other groups and 2ne1..

    Comon guys, we are here because we are CERTIFIED FANS and WE , the fans, enjoy their MUSIC.. Please make the competition healthy..

    Godbless y'all!


    Im out!

  35. Anonymous says:

    2NE1 all the way!!!:DDX_X

  36. Anonymous says:

    "I don't think polls should include 2NE1 anymore...their fans think that they are just the best in everything...they don't care about the quality. As long as 2NE1 is included they'll think it's the best perf.-Anonymous"


  37. Anonymous says:

    i dun tink english should be compared cuz dey are a korean grp..
    i feel that 2ne1 performace was quite good..
    cuz they actually have the rain effect and more props..
    and they actually opened their umbrella..
    however, i feel jewelry suits this song better..
    2ne1 is trying out the style..
    but maybe jewerly style is more for umbrella..
    for me both performance are dull as compared to rihanna's

  38. muti says:

    I like 2NE1 better... :)

Leave a Reply


blog comments powered by Disqus